Welcome to AfterEllen.com!

Enter your AfterEllen.com username.
Enter the password that accompanies your username.
News, Reviews & Commentary on Lesbian and Bisexual women in Entertainment and the Media

Ellen DeGeneres Joins "American Idol" as Fourth Judge

Fox announced in a press release today that out comedian and talk show host Ellen DeGeneres will be joining their popular singing competition show American Idol next season as the fourth judge.

"I’m thrilled to be the new judge on American Idol," said DeGeneres in a press release. "I’ve watched since the beginning, and I’ve always been a huge fan. So getting this job is a dream come true, and think of all the money I’ll save from not having to text in my vote.”

DeGeneres joins current Idol judges Simon Cowell, Randy Jackson and Kara DioGuardi, replacing departing judge Paula Abdul, who reportedly left the show due to contract disputes.

Creator and executive producer Simon Fuller said, "I could not be more excited to have Ellen join the American Idol family. Ellen has been a fan of the show for many years, and her love of music and understanding of the American public will bring a unique human touch to our judging panel. I can’t wait for this next season to begin.”

Ellen's Emmy Award-winning syndicated daily talk show, The Ellen DeGeneres Show, averages over 8 million viewers per episode, making it one of the highest-rated daytime TV shows.

American Idol averages between 20 and 30 million American viewers per episode, and is broadcast to over 100 nations outside the U.S. Although ratings have been slipping in recent seasons, the reality series is still one of the most-watched shows on primetime American television.

American Idol has never had an openly gay, lesbian or bisexual contestant. Several contestants have come out after appearing on Idol, however (or been out before the show and de-gayed their public profile during the competition), including Clay Aiken and, perhaps most famously, Adam Lambert, who was the runner-up last season and graced the cover of Entertainment Weekly with the headline "The Most Exciting American Idol Contestant In Years ... and Not Just Because He Might Be Gay."

Lambert, left, with Idol winner Kris Allen and host Ryan Seacrest

The show's ninth season kicks off in January 2010, and will feature appearances by guest judges Victoria Beckham, Mary J. Blige, Kristin Chenoweth, Joe Jonas, Neil Patrick Harris, Avril Lavigne, Katy Perry and Shania Twain.

DeGeneres's Idol gig will not interfere with The Ellen DeGeneres Show, which began its seventh season this week. "I'm not leaving here," DeGeneres reassured Ellen fans. "I'm going to have a day job and a night job — that is the times we're living in."

"Hopefully, I’m the people’s point of view because I’m just like you,” DeGeneres went on to add. “I sit at home and I watch it, and … I’m not looking at it in a critical way from the producer’s mind. I’m looking at it as a person who is going to buy the music and is going to relate to that person.”

DeGeneres's role on Idol makes her one of the world's most visible lesbians (if she wasn't already). It also means Ellen will join her wife Portia de Rossi (Better Off Ted), comedian Wanda Sykes (The Wanda Sykes Show and The New Adventures of Old Christine), and political commentator Rachel Maddow (The Rachel Maddow Show) as one of the few out lesbians — real or fictional — on primetime American television this season.

Watch the video of Ellen announcing the news on her show:

Kate Mac's picture

SO EXCITING!!!

OK I saw this announcement on Twitter and I really didn't believe it!!! I am so excited for Ellen and lesbians and gays across the land. Maybe people won't wait until their season is over to come out of the closet now that Ellen puts an "out and proud" face on one of the most popular shows. So exciting!!! Speaking of coming out. Share your Coming Out Story at www.shedate.com and maybe you'll win $$ but you will for sure get a free profile on the NEWEST LESBIAN DATING SITE- designed BY LESBIANS FOR LESBIANS!

"Yeah we both got dreams we can chase alone or we can make our own."

www.lezzbuzz.com @lezzbuzz  www.shedate.com  Enter the Coming Out Contest @ www.shedate.com you can win $$$$$$$

treasure's picture

yep...

im actually going to watch idol this season! :D

"Some women can't say the word lesbian...even when their mouth is full of one." - Kate Clinton

Sharon's picture

Haha

That's exactly what I said...
Fairburn's picture

Me as well.. I never watched

Me as well.. I never watched IDOL before :)
kandice's picture

yay

yaya im happy i love ellen and i love idol. but i dont like kara  ilike seeing paula haha
Courtney Dax's picture

Haha! Wait, what?

I honestly thought this was a joke, like one of your fake lesbian news skits that you do. Not that I'm not happy that Ellen got the gig! I'm estatic! It just seems a bit from left field, right?

Pinkishmel's picture

You are right

I'd have to agree. I think its a little odd that she'd make an apperance nevertheless be an judge on American Idol. I adore her and I will sure to be watching this coming season.
TS's picture

I agree as well. Is it wrong

I agree as well. Is it wrong that I kinda sorta think Idol is beneath Ellen? Like it's Ellen, ELLEN DEGENERES, she shouldn't be doing that sorta stuff you know what I mean?
swimgirl's picture

I thought this was a joke too!

But i'm really happy that it's not. I love american idol and i think that Ellen will be hilarious on the show. I can't wait :)
Amanda Kay! :)'s picture

not true about american idol contestants not being out..

IN the first season, Vanessa, who was in the top 10, was out as a lesbian.  I guess she just didn't talk about it. But she has mentioned later that she thinks the show is really homophobic and that they were encouraging her to stay in the closet.  She lives in Atlanta and is in a group now called Butterfly Stitch, that's how I know. 
Jamie All Over's picture

WOOT WOOT!!

I haven't watched the past couple of seasons but I will def be watching when it comes back on.

I thought it was a joke when I first saw it....it just kinda came out of now where.

But I think she will do a fantastic job!! 

 

If homosexuality is a disease, let's all call in queer to work: "Hello. Can't work today, still queer."
    Robin Tyler

theJadedRogue's picture

I don't know, at least Paula

I don't know, at least Paula had a musical background...  not sure, it won't make me watch Idle

 

http://theshoefitsmisscatherine.blogspot.com/?spref=fb '

tjr

 

Melissa Hsu's picture

Um

Wtf?
johnnynoname's picture

whoa! ELLEN!

i will definitely tune in to american idol next season. it's going to be exciting and less boring now that Ellen is on the show. yay to that! =)
Sara's picture

my only reaction

really?

really?

why?

akiraj's picture

Um

Because she's funny?

Anyway I'm so glad that she's the new judge because I haven't watched American Idol since Carrie Underwood won. SO maybe now I'll have a reason to watch. 

-------

Visit my favorite site www.thehungersite.com and click the big yellow button to help end world hunger. It's free to click- & c'mon it's a shiny yellow button!

Sara's picture

i agree

I love Ellen....but I dont understand why she's a judge.

She's there purely for entertainment purposes.

Chantal's picture

Ellen will be 1 the

Ellen will be 1 the entertainment and 2 the people's voice. She has been a fan for YEARS and like she has said on the announcement on her show, has never missed a show.

She'll be voicing what perhaps a large amount of the fans think when watching. She already said it that she doesn't have the 'technical' part down, but she is a fan of music and she bring more of the people's side to it

 

The Way The Cookie Crumbles

No Borders Allowed
psychonaut's picture

At this point the whole show

At this point the whole show is there for entertainment purposes =P

I think Ellen is fun and will do great, not to mention the visibility of a Queer person on one of the most popular TV shows.

Sara's picture

ok ok

i might actually tune in for an episode this season just to see ellen, but unless she has some technical training on pitch, rhythm, etc i dont think she should be the deciding vote to put singers through the various rounds.
pecola's picture

Ellen!

Wow, I thought this was just speculation when I saw this on twitter earlier but...wow...AWESOME! 

---

Justice consists not in being neutral between right and wrong, but in finding out the right and upholding it, wherever found, against the wrong. - Theodore Roosevelt

7Up's picture

cool for Ellen but.....

grrrr new reasons to tune into the creapy FOX network.... damn.... oh well, she'll probably get me to tune in a little, I ended up watching So You Think You Can Dance because of Ellen (which is actually pretty awesome)... too bad I don't trust FOX network politically, otherwise I would tune in more....   maybe Ellen could put the money she makes from FOX into organizations that fight for queer rights....
kris.'s picture

wha?

this is so random. not sure what i think about it, but my initial thought is that it's going to change the whole feeling of the show and now i think people might take it less seriously. even though ellen is very awesome, she's a comedian, not a musician.
☼♪♫hell girl's sister♥♪●♫♀+♀=♥'s picture

OMG OMG OMG OMG!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

OMG i'm just too happy Ellen is my older woman celebrity crush!!!!!! woooooow i'm sooo going to watch this season

 

True feelings can never be put into words.
therfore when you can't explain how you feel about someone that's when you know..

Gobias Somecoffee's picture

Ellen and Idol

  She's actually going to be a judge? Like a permanent judge?  I love Ellen but I saw her as a judge on SYTYCD and while her critiques were funny, I hope she doesn't do that every week. Because that would get tiring pretty quickly.  There have been so many problems with the judging, time wise, especially with having four judges last season that they could have just left it with three. I don't take Idol seriously at all so maybe this will be a fun change.   

 

roo_bear123's picture

Wow...this means I might

Wow...this means I might actually have to watch Americna Idol for the first time in my life. 
illmatic's picture

It's cool

The Idol producers probably saw her guest spot on SYTYCD and thought that the show could use her humor to lighten the show.  She's really positive, like Paula, so they wouldn't be losing that and she's always had Idol contestants on her show and has probably helped their ratings.  It was a no brainer.  A little strange but interesting.  We'll see.
michelle's picture

Okay, I'm an Ellen fan and

Okay, I'm an Ellen fan and all and am definitely excited to see her on AI, but this is just such odd news. I just hope she doesn't get too much backfire from the audience seeing as she has no musical background.

I mean, she'll be able to bring humor and the perspective of the average viewer into the critiques, but is that really what the show needs? And like another poster said, the constant jokes she did on SYTYCD, while absolutely hilarious, could become trite.

But on second thought, although Paula did bring a lot to the show, she never really gave critiques that were as helpful as the other judges anyway. Maybe Ellen will be even more help. We'll see I guess!

Renee's picture

Just had to say...

I love your icon! It's awesome!

~Renée

Sharon's picture

WOW!!

Every time I hear it I still freak out!! I love Ellen & now I get to watch twice a day twice a week starting January...

 At first I was like, wtf!! I watched her on SYTYCD and after a while it just got really weird 'cos all her comments were basically the same. I hope that's not gonna be the case w/ AI. 

 

I agree though, it's a little out there b/c we can all admit that she has little to no musical experience. At least she'll be funny 

Ines's picture

That is so awesome

I might watch it this season now. This might be good because she will actually be sober unlike some people.....

www.myspace.com/guitarrachica

 

Domino_Effect's picture

so i might actually start

so i might actually start watching this
Amanda's picture

so excited...

I might  just have to start recording the show. lool Ive never seen an episode.
L's picture

i love ellen but i might not

i love ellen but i might not watch american idol. i am not a fan of the show. i watch it if i dont have any / better shows to watch.
Carlotta's picture

Dropping ratings + popular

Dropping ratings + popular new judge = more viewers

The makers of the show definitely did their math-homework... I still don't think it's a good choice. Don't get me wrong, I love Ellen, but I think she should stick with what she does best: comedy! Her daytime show also lives from the funny interaction with her guests... I'd want a jude to be somewhat credible when it comes to music.

But maybe I'm just biased because the German version of the show is just plain crappy! Luckily none of the winners have ever released more than one album, the runner-ups are forgotten even faster. But everybody involved in the show (contestants and judges) does a great job in filling the cheap tabloids... 

I don't know what American Idol is like, the only good thing about the German one is the first few episodes when they show all the people auditioning who can't sing whatsoever and then are really disappointed that they can't move on to the next round. And they're so upset about the insults that one of the judges threw at them (he's been doing that for 6 seasons now, shouldn't be much of a surprise anymore)...

Queer Silver's picture

i hope...

that it's a good career move for her. we can't afford to lose another good lesbian on tv!

-MJ

Spread the RAINBOW!

http://mgayness.livejournal.com

Damask's picture

Wow

I thought this was a fake gay news article. Guess not. Random.
Hermes4X's picture

How much?

American Idol is owned by 19 Entertainment, the pigs that produce So You Think You Can Dance, and created a humiliating and demeaning piece to ridicule the two male dancers this summer. They never apologized for it either.  (Lythgoe was anything but contrite, and he's still hell bent on making dance "safe" for straight people, i.e. get rid of all those flaming poofs.)

Doesn't Ellen have enough money? It's sad to see her sell out like this!
7Up's picture

Yep, that's why I feel the cringe

Exactly why I get upset when Ellen and Lena Heady, and anyone else for that matter helps out the FOX network or anyone they work with. I just think it's messed up, I know these actors have to make career decisions, but I can't help but feel like they're putting money into the pockets of people who will put money into organizations that are fighting queer rights, promoting fundimentalist behavior, and doing shady things to get people like George Bush elected (I will never forget the elections, I just can't).......   I wonder what Rachel Maddow would say to this (privately of course)....

Of course it would give the whole thing a twist if Ellen negotiated a super hefty paycheck and then put all that money into organizations working for queer rights and visability, and supporting Obama's Health Plan! Then I could get into the idea a bit more....

North's picture

wow... I might even turn on

wow... I might even turn on the telly this season!

that show have really been going down the hill the past few years. Lets hope a little 'Ellen' can spice it up :)

Brynn's picture

they won't have to worry about ratings now

with ellen as a judge, you can bet that the ratings will shoot right back up!
Jay's picture

Wait, what?

Are you sure it's not April 1st? o.O

Love Ellen, but have no idea how this is going to work. *worries*
Claire's picture

yay

AWESOME!!! I am definitely watching it this season!  I hope their ratings go up astronomically!
Jes's picture

Will watch

I've rarely watched "American Idol," but now that Ellen is part of the program, I'll be watching for sure.
jackie's picture

totally thought this was fake

oh and I still will not be watching
oscartg's picture

How

How is Ellen qualified in any way to judge on American Idol, she doesn't have a music background at all. I guess she will be there for entertainment purposes not the help the contestants in anyway.  This is even more random that Alesha Dixon replacing Arlene on Strictly Come Dancing.

Tara's picture

Wow I might actually watch

Wow I might actually watch American Idol this time around. But only because Ellen's awesome

 

I think that's what I find most strange about this world. Nobody ever says how they feel. They hurt, but they don't cry out. They're happy, but they don't dance or jump around. And they're angry, but they hardly ever scream. Because they feel ashamed.

aphrodite's picture

oooohhhh

this makes my heart happy.
Dru42's picture

I wans't sure if I'd bother

I wans't sure if I'd bother to watch this ses, because I only watched like last ses. when they were to the Top 13 because of Adam. Then ended up liking Allison & Kris as well. XD

But then they said NPH would be in one ep, and I was all I'll watch at least that one and now this, so I'll probably watch it. XD

But I saw her ep of SYTYCD and that was just odd. lol. Like what was the point? But I think since this is more than just a guest judge thing she might actually take it more seriously and stuff. *Shrugs*

Also umh, I think it was kinda obvious that Adam was gay. lol. Like he said in Rolling Stone he was never really in the closet to start with. XD I mean, when would have been the best time to bring up BTW, I'm gay and not in a weird, shoved in way?

It was just more focused on him as a singer and performer than his sexuality. *Shrugs* I think they asked him what he wanted to do when those photos surfaced of him and an ex-boyfriend and he decided to like say nothing or something.

He wasn't trying to hide anything. If he was, he did a really bad job of it. XD And he in the Rolling Stone Article he practically starts with "It should come to no one as a surprise that I'm gay." So yeah. XD

But Clay Aiken, eek. That dude creeps me out and always has, and HE tried to hide shit... for years. lol. And look how that worked out for him. But obviously they are two TOTALLY different guys.

Yeah, I'll shut up now. XD 

.blue.'s picture

I

will def watch 4th season, never a big fan for american idol or any other idol, but for Ellen I'll follow through "Hey, you did nothing wrong" "I did, and I'd do it again"