![]() by Ace14Navigation |
Katie Couric: Will she stay or will she go?I hate writing this post. Or more accurately, it makes me sad that speculation about Katie Couric's tenure at as anchor of the CBS Evening News is one of the hot topics in the news these days.
If you haven't heard the story by now, Couric, her agent, the president of CBS news and the chairman of CBS met in late February and discussed Couric's future at the network. The CBS Evening News' ratings were low when she got there, and her presence and performance have not had the desired effect of elevating them. Consequently, her tenure at CBS — already referred to as "the Katie experiment" — is not really expected to last much longer than the 2008 presidential election. Sigh.
Now, I'll acknowledge up front that I have a lot of respect for Katie Couric, and I've been pulling for her from day one. I'll also sheepishly admit that I don't watch the CBS Evening News. (I work too late to catch it live. But if I did watch any evening news broadcast, it would be hers! I swear. Really.) Regardless, I understand that many people thought Couric was too "perky" and the wrong woman to be the first to independently anchor a U.S. evening news show, and I'm not going to argue with anyone who holds or held this position. Because it's too late for that. The die is cast. Whether or not you would have picked her, she got picked. And it's her success or failure — and frankly, it's looking a lot more like failure these days — that's going to affect the opportunities that other women journalists and newscasters have. And, frankly, this just sucks. Dan Rather's ratings trailed behind Peter Jennings' and Tom Brokaw's, and Bob Schieffer didn't break any ratings records, but their ratings didn't suggest anything about the viability of male journalists. But as other bloggers have noted before, women in traditionally male fields are held to a higher standard and evaluated differently. Remember that bizarre CNN promo when Paula Zahn joined the morning show?
The one that asked, "Where can you find a morning news anchor who's provocative, super-smart (and) oh, yeah, just a little sexy?" And was accompanied by what sounded like a zipper? (Jon Stewart did great coverage of this on The Daily Show.) Additionally, male anchors don't get covered in the Life and Style section of major newspapers via headlines such as "Why do all female newscasters look like 80s throwbacks?"
As AfterEllen.com blogger Roc noted last spring, Katie Couric has been challenged to maintain an arguably impossible balance of proving she's got the goods without being too nice or too mean. Which is a little harder than just showing up and doing her job. Apart from hoping that things turn around for her at CBS News, I guess the best I can hope for is that Couric's inability to raise the ratings will be seen as reflective of the general trend of waning interest in network news, as much as it is seen as a failure of "the Katie experiment." And I can hope that she'll end up in another job that's challenging and groundbreaking. One speculation, by the way, is that she'll replace Larry King at CNN. But his rep says, "Larry is going to be here for a long time." Feeding this speculation is the idea that Couric's alleged departure to CNN would bring Anderson Cooper to CBS to take over the anchor desk — which, I suppose, could be groundbreaking in a whole new way. Submitted by on April 15, 2008 - 1:33pm. |
User login |






I think if it wasn't Katie
Held to a higher standard.
I would have to agree with that. Back in the day Barbara Walters and then Connie Chung were both deemed to be the wrong women to co-host the ABC and CBS national news, respectively. And now Katie is the wrong woman to anchor the CBS Evening News. I do think that if another woman got the job, she too would be criticized...it would just be about something else.
We don't have this problem
We don't have this problem in the UK. We seem to have a lot of female news presenters, the main news channels here are the BBC and ITV (ITN broadcasts their news), and on those channels, we sometimes have co-presenters (male/female) but particularly on regional news, its female newcasters. On the ten O'Clock news, its mostly the men that present the news, our legend Sir Trevor McDonald anchors the News At Ten on ITV at 10pm. He's a legend so I forgive him! They do alternate though, for the main evening news at 6.30pm, using various news presenters. It's not just one.
But saying that, Channel Five have an independent female news presenter, Natasha Kaplinsky, who presents the news on the Channel on her own. She took over from Kirsty Young and has been a huge success. She presents the news in jeans believe it or not, and not behind a desk either. Brings a whole new format to news presenting!! But yeah, it's not that big a deal in the UK as it seems to be in the US!
BBC
You have Kirsty Wark (and her delicious accent) in the UK.
I've just read that Moira Stuart has just left but she was great too. If memory serves she used to read the morning news on BBC Breakfast when Natasha Kaplinsky was a co-host (after Sophie Raworth with Dermot Murnaghan then Bill "the beekeeper" Turnbull) before she moved to the one, six and ten o'clock news where Fiona Bruce and Sian Williams had already officiated.
Yeah, the UK is miiiiles ahead...
Belgium of all places has had many quality female news readers over the years too.
(yeah, I am a news geek).Another UKian
Mmmh! Finally I get the opportunity to post her picture here! Check out Business International on CNN International every weeknight at 22 GMT to see the bestest awesomest and gorgeousest News Anchor ever, Becky Anderson!
I would watch her but I will
bad timing
you have to give it to katie for trying...she left a cushy job at today to try something outside her comfort zone...
if you remember when she first started today they had her as "katherine" couric because she wanted to sound more serious...and the upper level guys wanted katie because it was a morning show...
with local news and network evening newscasts numbers taking a dive, i doubt she could have brought up any evening newscasts numbers...
I have a theory
Who holds the TV remote control during the evening news hours in most US homes? Maybe it's just the feminist in me, but I think some men simply don't want to watch a woman deliver the evening news. Pity them.
Leave Katie ALONEEEEEE!
I don't get it. And the more I think about this, the more confused I am. Because, initially, I thought of how popular and trendy, even in her 70s, Barbara Walters is...but now, she deals more with entertainment news, and is primarily known for The View these days-not her interviews with world leaders.
If CBS drops Katie Couric and their ratings continue to drop, I think they deserve it. Not only has the network "dumbed down" the news to cater to my generation (which I find incredibly offensive), but they've demanded unrealistic standards in an already fantastic reporter.
...and all was well, and the world smiled.