News, Reviews & Commentary on Lesbian and Bisexual women in Entertainment and the Media

dorothy snarker

by dorothy snarker

Gwyneth Paltrow's "W" cover: Apparently the W stands for 'Why?'

What is up with all these stars choosing truly tragic looks for their big comebacks? First Lauryn Hill, now Gwyneth Paltrow. Her cover photo for the new issue of W made me truly thankful for headline writers. Seriously, if it hadn't said “Gwyneth,” I would have had no idea. None.

Do the editors of W have some sort of secret (well, now, not-so-secret) grudge against Gwynnie? Perhaps the publisher had money on Saving Private Ryan to win best picture in 1998 and lost a bundle when Shakespeare in Love snuck in to steal the Oscar. Really, it’s the only explanation I can think of for making Blythe Danner’s daughter look like an unholy mash-up of bushy-eyebrowed Sienna Miller, passed-out Lindsay Lohan and a Communist-era East German transsexual.

And if you thought that was weird, wait until you see the inside photos (after the jump).

A rat, a sippy cup and a wan blonde. It’s like a bad nightmare Bette Porter had after watching too many Ingmar Bergman films.

Next, at first I thought this Cat on a Hot Tin Roof–inspired scene was kinda hot (especially since she seems to be portraying Brick instead of Maggie), but then I spotted the metallic mouse ears. Or are they spoons? Seriously, what the hell?

This next shot looks like it was taken for some twisted girls-with-canes-and thigh-highs fetish site. However, I refuse to Google to verify whether such sites exist. I’ll do anything for blog, but I won’t do that.

And finally, for a big splashy cover spread meant to herald her return, why on earth would Gwyneth pose like a dead person? Unless it’s meant as a refreshingly honest visual metaphor for the state of her career. In which case, very clever. Carry on.

browne's picture

As much as I think she's a

As much as I think she's a very good actress who makes good films, I've always found her quite hard to like. Woman, just cheer up and crack a smile already.
jennifer from pittsburgh's picture

"and a communist-era East

"and a communist-era East German transsexual..." LOL!
Slym's picture

Shaking My Head

There just aren't words so I'll just go by every word that you've typed Ms. Snarker.
dairyqueen's picture

ahm...strange

ok, these are really strange, weird pictures. Dislike the rat and I prefer the looks of dead Gwyneth. And was it any particular GDR/Eastgerman transsexual you were alluding to? I thought they looked more, um, gray...

Anyway: What I would find much more interesting is the article about Jodie Foster's Unstoppable Career that might even include pictures as well?

tide's picture

Creepy

She looks dead in the last two pictures.  Is she dead?
dypole's picture

Is that a Cher homage on the cover?

These pictures look like a mash-up between D&G and Marc Jacobs ads, and the ideas behind them are actually really interesting. The problem, though, is that Gwyneth Paltrow is such a bland and dull individual and thus doesn't fit into kooky, slightly disturbing photography like this.

"Out of the box is where I live." -Starbuck

Jessa's picture

Owww, that was even better then what I said.

You’re right, I’ll take interesting over ‘look pretty and stare at the camera’ any day. On its own, those pictures look like they have some pretty interesting concept behind them, problem is, Gwyneth is just so…blah. 

And is it me or is she giving of some strange ‘should be behind an acoustic gaiter at Woodstock’ type vibe with that…look.

newbie's picture

oddly sexy..

I never was a big Gwynneth-th fan (always feel like I’m lisping when I say that name), too meek and whimpery for my tastes.  So I am rather pleased she did something totally different.  Swerving off that rain swept boring road to drive through a little puddle.  Just to make a tiny, muddy splash.  I like that.;)  And I have to say, I like her look in a couple of the shots.   No comparison to poor clown lady.  That was just saaaadd.

Jessa's picture

WTF???

Um…weird. Maybe their road testing some new artsy photographer or something? But really, what’s with the cane and the crutches and the dead poses and the white drawstring cloths, some sort of strange asylum/hospital/crack den theme? 

Never liked her much, her mother on the other hand, it’s a good bet that she’s probably at least 30 years older then me, but seriously, she’s not bad for an old chook...so to speak (and comes across as totally lovely to boot). ^_^

katchoo's picture

WTH

What the hell were these people from W mag thinking?! And why there seem to be some sort of sexual aura (a bad, wrong, pathological, weird kinky aura, that is) in the last two pictures? Ew. Just... ew.

Always loving your comments, though, Ms.Dorothy Snarker. :) 

gooby's picture

Eyebrows... and not even

Eyebrows... and not even that but the COLOR of her eyebrows is what is freakin' me out. They stand out quite a bit especially in the picture where she's feeding the mouse. Tragic. And man, she used to be like the queen of fashion. Or maybe she just knows something we don't?! Whatever she knows, I don't wanna know if I get eyebrows like that. Harsh.
junglequeen's picture

HAHAHA!

this article was hilarious! the comments about the pictures made me seriously laugh out loud :D
lalinebrandao's picture

you know what?

you gotta give her some points for looking different now.

I mean, she's got an Oscar and all, but she's always the same girl with those big long yellow hair with no cut at all in every movie she make.

Omega II's picture

SPOON!!!

About the crutch pic- I don't think that is what the person who suggested "spooning with Gwyneth" meant.

 

I’ll do anything for blog, but I won’t do that.

Now I'm going to have that song stuck in my head.

 

"Bad jokes are us, ur me."

aaxander's picture

W pics usually freak me out

Anyone remember the Pitt-Jolie photo spread where the two of them were like a 50s family with perfect blond children?

Dairyqueen - I'm w/ you about the "Woman on Top" Jodie article. I hope it's online and I don't actually have to buy this crap.

As a side note - I always thought of Jodie as a "top", haha

smokinbluegrass's picture

So, what, we don't like a Gwyneth with eyebrows?

Really, that's the only "difference." Bushy is back, regarding eyebrows, anyway. So, they aren't blonde and plucked to arch-perfection. Wahhh-effing-waaahh. I've subscribed to the mag for 7 or 8 years. When I saw this cover, with GP's face sticking up outta my little mailbox, I thought, "Hey, Gwyneth's got some brows."
Andra8's picture

Yes!

I, for one, find big eyebrows on women very sexy.  I would not even say that Gwyneth has big eyebrows here.  They are merely more natural.  I never understood why women were 'supposed to' pluck their eyebrows when natural eyebrows usually better fit the face.  Just like I do not believe that women need to have diminuative noses or diminuative muscles to be attractive, I also do not believe that women need to have small, so-called feminine, lines for eyebrows to be sexy. 

I have not noticed that 'bushy' eyebrows are back, but I look forward to seeing more natural eyebrows in the future. 

Sutti's picture

The new look

"an unholy mash-up of bushy-eyebrowed Sienna Miller, passed-out Lindsay Lohan and a Communist-era East German transsexual"

Or Wendy James from Transvision Vamp. (http://static.flickr.com/20/70452459_1cb8528c6e_o.jpg) Either way...

The only time I've ever liked dear Gywnnie is when she stepped in at the very last second to replace Madonna for a British programme called Light Lunch (one of the presenters is a lesbian). She was highly personable and bloody good fun despite having a stinking cold.

Call Me Viv's picture

Did you say Transvision Vamp?

Wow, you mentioning Transvision Vamp just totally made my day. Although I'm not sure I like what you've equated Wendy James with. ;)

As for the W pictures... I may be part of a minority, but I like the cover shot in a way, bushy eyebrows, pose and all. I like that she looks so unlike herself there. As for the other photos, philistine that I am, I think they're "weird".

I wonder if anyone else has seen the episode where Gwyneth was at the Ellen Degeneres Show when she was promoting her movie "Proof". I thought it was hilarious when Ellen was talking through a megaphone telling people they should watch the movie and Gwyneth was completely embarrassed.

dietwyck_02's picture

Hmmm

You trash the photoshop one week, then complain that a cover shot isn't attractive the next.
shygurl99's picture

Creepy

It doesn't even look like her.I admit Gwyneth can come off as blah at times. I think it's because we have people like Paris Hilton and Lindsay Lohan all over the media and it makes her seem way too tame.

 "Life is either a daring adventure or nothing."-Helen Keller

artgirl007's picture

Gwyneth where art thou?

Either she has had extensive work done or her face or they sent a body double but there is no way that I can believe that those are pictures of Gwyneth Paltrow. She has lost her own face. However the pictures of Laura Dern were sensational. Her face is absolutely beautiful with the signs of age and all. What character!!!
SouthernCharma's picture

I think the pics are

I think the pics are interesting.  I'd rather see her doing something artistic than a photo shoot where she's pouring milk suggestively over herself or  eating hot dogs, etc.  I think Gwyneth likes to be a little different and I like her for it.  
abcdef's picture

The pics

The pics felt just wrong, the rat and sippy cups just don't mixed, don't they know the rat is grown enough to lick from the bowl.

Mmm...I have a hunch that she might think she's a Minnie Mouse incarnation.

Ninaka_'s picture

I find that she looks like

I find that she looks like Lucius Malfoy from Harry Potter.

User login

After Ellen home page on logo online