News, Reviews & Commentary on Lesbian and Bisexual women in Entertainment and the Media

The tomboy trap

Come this fall, you’ll be seeing fairies everywhere (and not the gay kind). Walt Disney Pictures officially announced the October 28th release of Tinker Bell, the first in a four-part feature-length DVD series all about Peter Pan’s tiny sidekick and her fairy friends. The voice cast stars some or our favorites, including America Ferrera, Anjelica Huston, Lucy Liu, Raven-Symoné and Kristin Chenoweth.

All the Disney hype is centered on the fact that this is the first time the audience will get to hear Tinker Bell (Mae Whitman) speak. But I’m more interested in the character of Fawn, who is voiced by none other than Ugly Betty herself. (She’s the one next to Tink in the picture below, wearing the pants and the “sensible” shoes. You can see where this is going, right?)

Even better than her more butch appearance and demeanor is the way she’s described in an early press release: “This rascally tomboy is full of mischief and mirth — she loves to tweak Iridessa [Raven-Symoné] just to see her glow. Fawn is always ready to play and the more rough-and-tumble the game, the better.” She loves to “tweak” her, huh? Is that what the kids are calling it these days? Sorry, I dyke-gress.

Don’t get too excited about the possibility of a Fawn/Iridessa pairing just yet, though. If pop-cult history is any indication, Fawn is just another in a long line of what I like to call the “wink, wink, nudge, nudge” tomboy. Everything about this thinly veiled lesbian character — her clothes, behavior, interests (usually playing sports) — screams “butch,” but the writers always fall short of outing her. Instead, they slap on the non-threatening “tomboy” label and either set her up in an awkward boy-crush or strip her of her sexuality all together. And this play-both-sides-of-the-fence formula seems to work magic: Lesbians adopt the tomboy as one of their own — hey, it’s not like we have that many openly gay characters to relate to — and the general viewing public also embraces her, since she’s never revealed to be anything more than a bit on the boyish side. It’s a win-win situation for the producers. But we, of course, have to settle for lesbian subtext and watered-down versions of ourselves yet again.

One of the best examples of this kind of character is Peppermint Patty from the Peanuts cartoon. The baseball-playing (wink, wink), Birkenstock-wearing (nudge, nudge) tomboy is considered just one of the guys. She even calls her bud, Charlie Brown, “Chuck.” But she also has a special nickname of her own that’s given to her by her best friend, Marcie: It’s “Sir” (wink, wink, nudge, nudge times a thousand). Marcie follows her around in awe, hanging on her every word. And in return, Peppermint Patty is fiercely protective of Marcie. Sounds a little like the makings of a first crush, doesn’t it? Well, they do have a secret thing for someone, but it’s not a girl—that would be too controversial for the mainstream audience to watch with their impressionable kids (I guess the slutty-looking toons from Bratz is more their speed.) While it’s clear to anyone with half a brain that Marcie and her sir are crushing on each other, we’re led to believe they somehow like blockhead Charlie Brown instead.

Now, I could probably let a sexually ambiguous cartoon character slide every once and again…if that’s where it ended. But the tomboy issue isn’t just confined to children’s entertainment. We’ve seen this character type pop up dozens and dozens of times in teen and adult TV shows (Jo from The Facts of Life, anything starring a young Kristy McNichol) and movies (Idgie from Fried Green Tomatoes, anything starring a young Jodie Foster).

I’m not saying all tomboys grow up to be gay, but some do (and probably more than not). So, in the interest of fairness and realism — two things we know Hollywood really cares about — it’s way past time to let a tomboy or two come out of the closet on the boob tube and the big screen.

What do you think? Is there a TV or film character you want to switch from a tomboy to a tomboi?

  • Ms.Anthrope's blog
  • Login or register to post comments
  • gypsy80's picture

    Peppermint Patty

    I know how the girls are supposed to like charlie but i never bought it. P. Patty was always getting charlie brown out of some kind of mess. My favorte reference to Marcie and P. Patty was in an episode of family guy. Peter goes around looking for his old girlfriends and at one door is Peppermint Patty, looking the smae but with a more huskier voice, after Peter tells her how great she looks, Peppermint Patty says its all do to my partner and Marcie comes to the door "who is it sir"..LMAO
    Batman's picture

    I'm so stupid!!

     

    I didn't even realize that...I watch Family Guy everynight and that was one refrence I never got!! wow...thanks.

    ______________________________________

    Cloverfield? 1-18-08-underground.com...

    gypsy80's picture

    LOL

    No problem, thats what i'm here for.  :)
    mddrugger's picture

    Family Guy

    HILARIOUS! That made me so happy because seeing those peants gals as grown up dykes totally made sense and made the connections for me that I never did on my own... I guess that's what AE bloggers are for!
    heylookachicken's picture

    Hmmm

    Is it me, or is Fawn checking out the other fairies?
    mibtc86's picture

    Kristen Chenowith

    :). she was great in Wicked (broadway show; just saying).

    Charmed71's picture

    KRISTIN CHENOWETH!!!!

    OMG! Kristin Chenoweth! I love love love love love her! She will be perfect for the role of one of the fairies. Her voice is so childish but fun! I'm gonna watch this when it comes out just to see her. The fact that there is a "tomboy" fairie doesn't hurt either. Haha.

    As for the question of tomboy to tomboi....i'm not really sure. I don't watch too much tv anymore. gah!

    -Lori
    queeniefakesit's picture

    i mean

    in that second pic the one in the brown is obviously checkin out the one in the yellow, and the one in the yellow has the body language of 'i'm gonna turn my body toward you to show interest but i'm gonna look away because i'm all coy and shit.'

    i love gay undertones.

     

     

    I got a dick like a mule...with a big dick.

    My Name Is Tara's picture

    Yellow clothing fairy...

    Hahaha. Your comment about the yellow clothing fairy pretending to be coy is funny.
    KellySue69's picture

    Hmm..

    I'd have to say Lilly from Hannah Montana. =D
    Oh, come on! Her and Miley are like little Spashley wanna-be's!

    Sorry..I'm just having mega Spashley withdrawl. -_-;

    jill-bennett-fan's picture

    i agree

     and also  sam from i carly  on teen nick                                                                

    sam and carly are just like  miley and lily

     

     

    im a big kid and i love nickelodeon and disney channel 

     

    queeniefakesit's picture

    OMG SAM AND CARLY

    First time i watched that show i was like OMG the tomboyish character named Sam. who likes to eat. Of course. (why are the dykish chicks always named 'Sam' or 'Alex'? We can't get names like Janet or...Debbie? Or Keisha? Digress.)

    But yeah. They're totally gayish. And for a tweenie show, it's really good. No joke.

     

    I got a dick like a mule...with a big dick.

    conrad22's picture

    The fist time I saw Lilly I

    The fist time I saw Lilly I thought "wow she's gay" and then I remembered it was Disney and gay people do not exist...
    luxury_bus's picture

    I don't understand how

    I don't understand how parents can accept the Bratz generation either--quite frankly, all of the Bratz dolls (or is it dollz?) look like two-cent whores.

    And I love the idea of a Tinkerbell movie--because I loved Tinkerbell in Peter Pan... young crushes, you know--but I am praying to God that Tinkerbell and her friends do not turn out looking like Barbies in this. Disney has a rep for transforming everyone and their mothers into hott little bodies and pairing them up with random, yet handsome, boys.

    And Idgie isn't even a questionable lesbian. I have straight friends, who upon their first viewing of FGT, who shout out, "My goodness! Those two are lovers!" It doesn't take a lesbian to recognize some massive subtext.

    You can't shake hands with a clenched fist.
    [Indira Ghandi]

    Dont_ask_dont_tell's picture

    Fried Green Tomatoes

    Have you ever read the book?? it is very clear that ruth and idgie are more than friends in the book..... its very good.
    luxury_bus's picture

    Yes, I love the book! I

    Yes, I love the book! I feel the movie glossed over a lot of the Idgie/Ruth relationship (as well as the relationships with Eva) and didn't stay true to the main ideas Fannie Flagg had for their characters, and that disappointed me a bit... but I liked the movie mainly because it had Mary Stuart Masterson and Mary Louise Parker in it, both of whom I love.

    But yes, the book was much much better. =]

    You can't shake hands with a clenched fist.
    [Indira Ghandi]

    rstipati's picture

    It was almost much worse

    As I recall, an early script was leaked in which both Ruth and Idgie were put in straight relationships. There was a pretty big commotion as I recall (GLAAD might have been involved) and the final script was a compromise.

    Your friend,
    Rusty
    http://lezbang.com/

    luxury_bus's picture

    Ouch! That would have been

    Ouch! That would have been very, very bad. I know the movie tried to play up the Idgie/Grady romance a little but... ick, to be honest, haha. I'm glad that there was some subtext/relationship between Idgie and Ruth. I doubt I would like the movie as much as I do if there hadn't been any ;) Thanks for the info!

     

    You can't shake hands with a clenched fist.
    [Indira Ghandi]

    Ms.Anthrope's picture

    Hard to believe...

    But to this day, I still have arguments with straight friends who insist Idgie was only a tomboy and she was just “close friends” or "sisters" with Ruth (*vomit*). That's why I included her. I don’t know how they managed to miss all the lesbian subtext in the movie, but I hand them a copy of the book and that usually shuts them up. Unfortunately, it’s rare to have a book to back you up or provide you with additional insights into a character’s sexual orientation. If you still think it's impossible for people not to get it, look up the movie on imdb.com and read the "gay" thread in the message board at the bottom.
    mddrugger's picture

    Well that's just sad

    FGT is my favorite book of all time, when ever I've felt low I've consoled myself with the idea that someday my bee charmer will come. I would like to not need to be rescued though...

    It's my great wish that LOGO or Showtime or someone will make a nice long miniseries of FGT complete with a love scene we never got in text and all the parts about Sipsy's family. Seriously- way to overlook a third of the book to make it simply a euro-centric woman-power for housewives flick!

    luxury_bus's picture

    You need better straight

    You need better straight friends ;)

    I don't know... people can be blind to things they don't want to see? Or us lesbians manipulate every female/female situation into a romance, haha.

    You can't shake hands with a clenched fist.
    [Indira Ghandi]

    luxury_bus's picture

    Also...

    The best tomboy ever? Kara "Starbuck" Thrace, in Battlestar Galatica. She even calls President Roslin (played by beatiful Mary McDonnell) "sir". =P

    You can't shake hands with a clenched fist.
    [Indira Ghandi]

    BijouxIce's picture

    You are so right!

    Also, one of the best mistakes I ever made ;) was because of my huge crush on Sarah Connor in Terminator 2 - I fell real frackin' hard for a woman who looked just like her from the neck down and had a similar personality and attitude. Sarah was clearly using all of the men in her past to help train young John to become the hero of all (hu)mankind, but it didn't mean she actually loved them, she was just doing it for the future of humanity.

    "Never explain, never complain." - Katherine Hepburn

    luxury_bus's picture

    I would totally try to date

    I would totally try to date someone who liked like Sarah Connor/Linda Hamilton from the neck down! That bod is hott. =]

    And yes, I totally agree with your theory of whether or not she really loved him, haha.

     

    You can't shake hands with a clenched fist.
    [Indira Ghandi]

    cortinacolorado's picture

    I must confess...

    I've held my guilty pleasure secret for too long now, but I actually did watch 7th Heaven just to indulge in fantasies about Jessica Biel's sporty babydyke character, Mary Camden. I know, I know, they gave her a serious boyfriend in New York or some dumb thing (and lost me as a viewer forever, I tell you). But I can't have been the only one to have seen through that ruse, can I?

    And imagine if she had come out... What an opportunity that would have been to address the issue of homophobia in the Christian church! Alas, she didn't, they didn't, and now Jessica has turned into a boring, brooding femme-bot.

    Reign's picture

    Mary!

    Total agree Mary Camden, had more than a lil tomboy thing going on. I wish they just let her at least have a girl crush. She was the only reason I even watched 7th Heaven. When she left so did I.

    Ms.Anthrope's picture

    Re: Mary

    The show went on after Mary left? Seems rather pointless. ;)

    cortinacolorado's picture

    I must confess...

    Ergh...duplicate posting. Sorry!
    coffeesky's picture

    ITA about Mary Camden! 

    ITA about Mary Camden!  Back then the WB was all about Mary Camden and Joey Potter for me!!!
    pouik's picture

    the famous five

    george, in the famous five, refuses to be called georgina, dresses like a boy, etc...

    ok, i'm slightly off-topic, because it's a book, not a movie, but this character made my childhood ! 

    Glindared's picture

    introducing myself

    Often when I introduce myself, or if someone asks me my name...I always say "my name is Patti XXXXXXX, just think of peppermint patti and ya can't go wrong. I often tag people in my mind with nicknames to help me remember their names by association. Which is why I often give other people the nickname association ahead of time. I've ben doing this for years, so I find it amusing that the "Peppermint Patti" character is part of a blog about cartoon characters and how gay are they?
    Just_Alice's picture

    Jewel Staite, aka 'Kaylee Frye' in FireFly!

     

    Jewel Staite, aka Kaylee Frye in FireFly! She made makes my toes curl!

    Mae Whitman? Oh, Yeah!

    ...and Charlie Brown? Can you say 'Beard'?

    Making Tink and the other faeries sexy? In that dress, 50 years too late - obviously aimed at teen boys!

    LoveLillianGish's picture

    the new Disney fairy flick

    I agree with you that its 50 years too late, but its not at all aimed at teen boys. I can't think of any teen boys who would go see it.(though you may have been joking) Its made for tiny children say 5-12. But as a side note Firefly was great, mostly because it was a Joss Whedon work. But to go back to the new film...I'm tired of the new computer animation. It looks really bad in many cases such as Shrek and other projects that were taken on too soon for the technology to develop more. Though I have to say Finding Nemo was done really well. (they actually had to redo the ocean because it looked too realistic)

    As far as gay undertones go... I watched about 4 episodes of that show...hm...Gossip Girl (then I got bored) but Serena and Blair have some gay subtext going on.

    ilive2play7's picture

    GG

    I've been reading the Gossip Girl books and in book one it says that Serena and Blair kissed in 8th grade? dont quote me when they were drunk and in Chucks hot tub, apparently the book alludes that Blair felt more for Serena in that kiss...ah my secret love for GG!
    balaustine's picture

    I always thought Jo and

    I always thought Jo and Blair from The Facts of Life were secretly together.  Well, me and almost every other lesbian on the planet. 
    Just_Alice's picture

    Jo + Blair

     

    Blair was definately a repressed closet case! But we all know that when the lights went out...

    Gawd, my mom had me watching all these old shows - Yay, Cable & DVD Box-Sets!

    angel winters's picture

    speak

    I'm sorry but can someone tell me if the tinker bell in the Robin Williams movie hook....Julia Roberts staring tinker....is the same character as the one mentioned above...and if so...wouldn't that have been the first time tinker bell ever spoke.
    jill-bennett-fan's picture

    yes

    the tinker bell played by julia roberts and the one mentioned here are the same 

    Ms.Anthrope's picture

    Disney

    I don't think Disney considers the Tinker Bell from Hook the same. But yes, that's true. Technically, this is the first time the animated version will speak.
    anonyme's picture

    Now and Then

    I haven't seen the movie in a long while but I vaguely recall Christina Ricci as a chest-binding tomboy who inexplicably falls in love with a male character and yet grows up to be Rosie O'Donnell. Even at twelve, I was baffeled by that transition.
    mija's picture

    i just hate screening

    «Roberta, played as a girl by Christina Ricci and as an adult by Rosie O'Donnell was originally intended to be a lesbian, but the lines establishing this were edited out after preview audiences claimed to find them 'confusing.' »  http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Now_and_Then_(1995_film)#Trivia

    Shele's picture

    Yeah, but we all knew

    the character was gay.  It was just a case of "don't ask, don't tell".
    guiltyone58's picture

    NOW AND THEN!

    hahaha, i remember thinking the same exact thing when i was younger!

    her name was Roberta or something and i remember thinking...wtf...she HAS to be gay!

    sgtmian's picture

    kristin chenoweth! mae

    kristin chenoweth! mae whitman! ..i want to see this.

    User login

    After Ellen home page on logo online