News, Reviews & Commentary on Lesbian and Bisexual women in Entertainment and the Media

"Gossip Girl": Will you tune in this week?

"Oh, lordy" is what immediately came to mind after I watched the first episode of Gossip Girl, the new teen soap-drama that premiered last week. In this context, "oh, lordy" sort of means "if you have a high tolerance for self-serving, self-indulgent, puddle-deep, cliched characters or and an even higher tolerance for not-too-clever, predictable, not-much-nuance writing, then this show is awesome! There are some very informative reviews here, here and here.

This isn't a recap, because nothing that was said in the episode is worth restating anywhere. The show stars a very charismatic Blake Lively as Serena van der Woodsen (I like Blake a whole lot better than her brother Eric, who played creepy secret videotaper Mark on The L Word) Leighton Meester as Blair Waldorf , Penn Badgley as Dan Humphrey, Chace Crawford as Nate Archibald, Taylor Momsen as Jenny Humphrey and Ed Westwick as Chuck Bass. In a capsule, Serena and Blair are best friends. Well they were. Serena left school and returned to school under mysterious circumstances. Blair's boyfriend, Nate, also has a thing for Serena, which of course drives much of the drama between Blair and Serena. Dan and his little sister Jenny are the "not so rich kids" at the rich kids' school. Dan has crushed on Serena from afar, and freshman Jenny is in awe of the hip in-crowd at her new school. The show moves along through the use of a voice over by “The Gossip Girl,” a blogger who has her finger on the pulse of this teen grouping from this prep school.

Here's a disclaimer: I do realize that this was the pilot, and pilot episodes tend to be over-the-top when it comes to introducing and establishing the motivations of each character. So, much of what I saw regarding the lack of character depth and forced dialogue might be due to the Pilot Effect. I have other disclaimers and biases that I must voice.

I assume that I am not a member of the target audience. This show clearly was not written with me in mind. Now, having said that, I do question exactly with whom in mind it was written! High school kids sitting at bars of luxury hotels drinking martinis, or strolling through Central Park smoking marijuana, or hosting parent-approved, parent-encouraged make-out cocktail parties with an open bar of free-flowing beer, wine and champagne for all minors?! Seems as though the show may have been written with rehab centers in mind. There were two near date rape situations, as well, so maybe it was written with young sex offenders in mind? Oh, and there was a ton of cool cell phone use, so maybe it was written with Verizon, T-Mobile or AT&T in mind — or was it more Nokia and Motorola in mind? I'm really glad the kids are rich, because the way they text messaged every two seconds, they all must have an unlimited text plan — and those things are expensive!

Oh, and I've never read the Gossip Girl book(s), so maybe I can't have a true appreciation for the fact that the first book predated the MySpace and Facebook communities that so many folks are involved in. The first book actually predated how "gossip" is instantly transmitted these days. So that was probably a cool read five years ago. But watching this "instant gossip" transmission on my screen seemed both blasé and really annoying. Isn't it great that within minutes of something really awful happening like almost being sexually assaulted freshman year by a bad Bret Easton Ellis character wanna-be named Chuck, the entire school will know? Kids now are so lucky. Ain't technology cool!

I must confess that girl rivalries over cheating boyfriends cause extreme narcolepsy. Well, in me at least. Granted, a girl getting drunk and sleeping with her best friend's boyfriend would end many friendships, but when the girl who was cheated on remains the girlfriend of the boy who did the cheating, it just makes my eyes feel quite heavy and makes my neck ache as it snaps forward in that instant slumber. For those who will continue to watch the show, please wake me when something original happens.

Besides, we all know that Blair and Serena actually have that love thing for each other (Sarah and Lori think so too) and Nate is just a tool! Why is this show tiptoeing around the lezzies-in-uniform reality? Nobody does uniforms the way we do. My goodness, these girls wear miniskirts, white button-down blouses and TIES! Tell me there is no love in the air between these prep school sisters.

The show is not just about kids; it's also about their parents. Again, personal bias, but I prefer that children be raised in orphanages rather than in hypercritical, narcissistic uncaring hotels — uh, I mean homes or fabulous apartments — with distant, uncaring but fabulously rich parents. Blair's mother controls the outfits her daughter wears and says Blair will never be more attractive nor as thin and desirable as she is right now at 17. Ah, nothing like cuddling up to mommy's bosom for such loving reassurance. Serena's mother bought her daughter a dress for a party, but after learning that Serena wasn’t going attend the party, decided to keep the dress for herself. This same mother has a young teen son who is recuperating from a suicide attempt and who must be kept from view of the other mothers — I guess because maybe they will all begin to play the game "I can top that!" by comparing and contrasting suicide stories of their own youth?

This is a minor bias but I really detest "shipper names" and using first letters of a person's name as nicknames, so in this case the overuse of B (Blair) and S (Serena) really was BS to me and that's never good. I also hate text speak. So as I watched all the synchronized texting on screen, I felt an urge to text my own message "r u 4 reel? y m i wtchn ths ish? I is L8 4 bed."

OK, I swear this is my final complaint about the pilot. I don't enjoy shows that parade around blatantly token minorities. In this case, there was an Asian schoolmate that we might as well call earring and an African-American chum we should just call bracelet — because these two characters were nothing more than accessories to B. I mean Blair. I do hope they have more to do in later episodes, like, you know, get their own lives. I'm not hopeful.

In conclusion, I have seen the show referred to as the East Coast prep school version of The O.C. Well, I never did sit through an entire episode of The O.C. and they had the beach and surf scenes, so yes, I found myself asking myself why was I watching this version without the beach and surfing. But even with all of my disclaimers and biases and nitpicks, I can also see what's attractive about the show. Teen age angst on screen dates back to Rebel Without a Cause, so the concept isn't going anywhere. And as long as teens struggle with finding their places in the social order of school and in society in general, shows like this will exist. Make no mistake, I didn't find anything particular insightful nor redeeming about the show, but if you like mindless trashy entertainment or a decent “bad” TV show like the ones Aaron Spelling churned out in his heyday, Gossip Girl as a trashy teen soap may hold your interest for a while.

  • roc's blog
  • Login or register to post comments
  • Angeelaa's picture

    I'm only going to

    I'm only going to watch if the girls start sleeping together. Though I have a feeling I wouldn't be the only one, right? ;)






    http://myspace.com/ckhinrich
    pens's picture

    why don't you tell us how

    why don't you tell us how you really feel? ;)
    roc's picture

    ....

    Heh. The crazy thing is I can see the potential appeal of the show:) There is something about Blake Lively that I found intriguing both in looks and in acting nuance. The outdoor shots of NYC was also a nice touch and the pacing of the episode was on target as well, imo. I didn't find the show any more or less inane than Beverly Hills 90210. I'm sure there are those AE members that enjoyed the pilot and plan to watch. Heck, I might watch it at least one more time to see if the writing moved past the Pilot Effect! Or...maybe not:)
    misajingles's picture

    I watched the pilot also

    Mostly just to support Kristen Bell, and to check for subtext possibilities. I haven't yet decided if I'm going to continue to watch. The narration was little too close to the Veronica Mars Voice Over and I kept expecting Kristen to walk on screen, make fun of all the little preppie kids, insult someone, and walk away.

    But of course... my dreams hardly ever come true.

    thesupernova's picture

    me too

    i thought if i watched and was at least able to hear kristen bell talking it would be better than nothing at all. but holy crap i dont think i can sit thru another full episode. it does help the girl who plays serena is very hot. i think ill try one more episode.
    i cant wait for heroes (ive never actually watched an episode). and bring on Fanboys:)

    Niuxita's picture

    Oh, I am so glad I'm not the

    Oh, I am so glad I'm not the only one who hated the pilot. Everything was just so predictable and the cliches were no longer cliches, they were anvils. And we're supposed to side with Serena but I find Blake Lively kind of bland and Blair's character way more interesting. Then again, I have a history of siding with the cheatees/third wheels in a relationship, so maybe that's why. I am not kidding when I say the only thing that might keep me watching is the love-hate thing one of the dads and one of the moms have going on. Otherwise, meh, all the teen drama is way too dramatic for me.
    lawnsprite's picture

    Mindless Pleasure

    For some reason, my TV viewing is all about stupid shows; well, with a few exceptions: Battlestar, Heroes, etc.  Can't we just love the predictable drama and the crazy party scenes?  One does need a break from reality.  I know I do.  I don't like using my brain all the time ;)  Besides, it's eye candy not some heavy show with afterschool like morality tales.
    MsSullivan's picture

    Dear Gossip Girl Team:

    If I, a recovering teen drama junky (who is still the occasional purveyor of O.C. quotes - shameful!) & Kristen Bell lover can't get through your series premiere, you might need to be concerned. Not like I'm the TV be all and end all or anything, but I usually take to this stuff pretty quickly- even when the characters are whiny and/or annoying, I'll still watch for the love to hate factor. I found Gossip Girl to be boring, which is pretty much my TV kiss of death.
    roc's picture

    ....

    Yes, I was waiting for something to happen. But alas all that did happen was predictable. And Chuck had some of the worst dialog in the episode. It's hard to take a guy seriously when he says things like "seal the deal" and "Good thing I'm connected" Good grief... Not knowing the books at all, I do hope "more entertaining" plot twists are to come. And by more entertaining I actually mean interesting and not pedestrian girl rivalry Lunesta substitute plots that cause drowsiness.
    dypole's picture

    O rly?

    I would hate this show if it wasn't for the fact that it is EXACTLY like what my ex said Manhattan prep school/upper society life was like as a teenager. It's kind of creepy, actually.

    "Out of the box is where I live." -Starbuck

    mossy's picture

    lol

    You are always good for a laugh. Sadly I think this review is more clever than the show. and even if this is how life really is in a Manhattan prep school it's a TV show so it needs to be more than just a real depiction especially since the depiction is so cookie cutter and not too redeeming or inspiring. As fiction it needs to be more interesting than what was shown. I missed the beginning of the pilot but no matter I got the point of the show pretty quickly. Maybe if it was a documentary it would be great to watch the real power struggles of rich white kids but for a fictional TV show I need more than what appeared in the first episode. I'm far from a TV elitist and watched my share of Aaron Spelling junk. I thought the boy that was the rock star's kid was cute and played his role very sincerely. That's about it. Even the music seemed dated.
    franny's picture

    I liked it because

    If nothing else the pilot did a really good job of staying true to the books. Plus, could Blake Lively be any hotter? I'm gonna go with no :O)
    mossy's picture

    I agree

    I think she's beautiful but not in the typical way and that's very hot! Recapping this show might be fun to read. There is enough "interest" in the show for people to watch but it's also "bad" enough to make good fun with. I can see this show as a real guilty pleasure for some.
    Leahashra's picture

    Can't Help But Love It

    I can't help it--I like the show. I've been onto the books since the release of the first Gossipgirl (I stumbled upon it when I was cruising a Borders in my blissfully-unaware-of-my-sexuality-heyday), and I love it.

    As an East Coaster (Massachusetts by blood, Manhattan, NYC by heart and soul and Jewish family...:-) hehehehe), I'm actually thrilled to see a show on tv that isn't in freakin' California. The Hills. The O.C. Gah.

    And although the show isn't completely like the book (the characters of Dan and Jenny are definitely not what I imagined them as nor how the author described them), it satisfies my craving for fantastical East Coast upper class folkies in a realistic environment living mainly unrealistic lives for 95% of us.

    Call me easily satisfied, but I'll be watching each show just as closely as "Gossipgirl" watches all of the people.
    Starshone's picture

    The book series it's based on...

    ...is my absolute guilty pleasure series :D
    MsWoo's picture

    I loved it.

    Guess I am the only one. Of course, a lot of it had to do with the dark haired girl looking so much like a young Eliza Dushku. And I agree with Sarah and Lori re the attraction between Selma and Blair. (Yes, I know that is not the character's name, but I like Selma Blair, and this had that whole Cruel Intentions feel to it, which also made me happy).

     

    I can't wait til Wednesday. I want the Eliza look-a-like to admit she has not been having sex with her boyfriend and is pissed off not that he cheated, but with WHOM he cheated. Let's face it, she wanted the blond one for herself.

    tarrabbit's picture

    I - somewhat - agree

    i admit i'm not in their demographic, but i found this show to be much more interesting to other choices, and similar to some of what I saw in high school to keep me watching for a few eps.

    as a new young adult show, it has the essense of what could grow to be more quality writing - far better than L-Word or SON could ever hope to be at this point - and it looks professional and polished.

    i won't dismiss it so easily, not yet.

    OrBabylon's picture

    Teen Drama Junky

    I really hate to admit it but I liked the pilot, even when I wanted to hate it.  I only tuned in at first because of Blake Lively as I loved her in Traveling Pants.  This young actress has that "it" factor that just draws you in.  I'm also a sucker for when the geek or unpopular kid gets the girl (Dan & Serena). I think I will give it one more look and if it's still good, try and work it into my over crowded TV schedule this fall.
    roc's picture

    .....

    I do like the "look" of the show and as I said I'm intrigued by Blake Lively and if the show can toss in a little lesbian subtext (or more) into the mix then I can live with my nitpicks of what the pilot depicted:) I'm way easy like that.

    mossy ~ I can't see any recapping happening for this show unless it gets a whole lot "gayer" :) but hey, never say never, right? I agree with you though, there are some wickedly fun things to be snarky about.

    tight's picture

    Not awful

    I read this blog earlier and laughed but i hadn't seen the show yet. so i watched tonight and it was tolerable. but dude when the asian girl and the african-american girl appeared on screen both of them saying stupid crap i busted out laughing so hard thinking of them as earring and bracelet! that stuck with me and cracked me up. blake lively is ok but the dark haired girl is pretty attractive too. the parents were in this too much tonight. and another "open bar" party for the minors. how kewl.
    tight's picture

    still watching?

    Roc Just curious if you are still watching?

    User login

    After Ellen home page on logo online