Welcome to AfterEllen.com!

Enter your AfterEllen.com username.
Enter the password that accompanies your username.
News, Reviews & Commentary on Lesbian and Bisexual women in Entertainment and the Media

roc

by roc

Jennifer Hudson joins "Sex and the City"

Jennifer Hudson, best known for Dreamgirls, has been cast in the movie version of Sex and the City, which starts filming in New York next week. The casting of Hudson was wonderful news to read. But I was trying to recall what character Hudson played in the original series — and then of course I quickly remembered that there were no women of color in that group. But great, there will be one now! Except it looks like another "black best friend" role, and for an Academy Award–winning actress no less.

OK, OK, so she's not going to be a friend; she's going to be the personal assistant to Carrie Bradshaw (Sarah Jessica Parker). (Has Carrie moved up in the world if she's now in need of a PA?) But I'm guessing that as the personal assistant, Hudson's character will be the voice of reason, give sage advice, helping to keep the neuroses of her boss under control and all with humor and a good dose of strong, sensible black womanness. Or wait, maybe Hudson will have a sex and the city love interest of her own? Yes, I know. I doubt it, too. Am I being too narrow in my assumptions? I hope so. Maybe there is more to the role than what meets the cynical eye. Please?

I do want to look forward to the movie, but I have a confession. I was never really a fan of Sex and the City. I know, I know, I have lost good friendships and the respect of many over this admission in the past. And I have had to uncomfortably suffer through intense stares of derision when I have said this out loud. I have even had an unkind word or two tossed my way when I have uttered this apparent heresy. So I do know that my opinion is not just an unpopular opinion, but may actually be perceived by many as an insane opinion! But I swear I wanted to like it. I even tried to watch the DVD sets and never made it past season two. Admittedly, there was some cute, cute and some clever, clever per episode, but at the end of the day it was women looking for men and wondering why the men weren't looking back, or if the men did look back, then the question became what to do with the men that did show interest and if they showed too much interest what to do with them at that point. It was men and angst and then some additional angst and some additional men. I couldn't deal with that weekly. And it turns out I couldn't deal with that in a DVD marathon either.

I never made it to Carrie's kiss of Alanis Morissette in season three, nor did I witness first hand Samantha's (Kim Cattrall) very brief lesbian relationship with Maria (Sonia Braga) because by the time that story line rolled around in season four, all I wanted to know was how in the world some one like Samantha managed not to have had a lesbian experience any time sooner?!

I do know that the show was wildly popular with most women and met with tremendous critical success. I was sad to see the show end because it ended a six-year run with four strong female leads. I actually enjoy the actresses and even some of the humor of the original series (if not the ongoing theme of men are from Mars and women are from the rest of the entire galaxy). By the way, the story arcs for the characters in the movie version are being guarded tighter than nuclear secrets, so there is not much to offer on that front. It seems that all that's really known about the movie is that it is taking place four years after the show's final TV airing and that's why the casting of a personal assistant to Carrie might strike even additional interest in some of the more faithful followers.

As for me, with Jennifer Hudson joining the fray (and yes, I almost hate to say it, but I’d rather there be a woman of color in the cast than not) and with out-and-proud Cynthia Nixon agreeing to reunite with the original cast, it seems I just may have my rooting interest in this venture! After all, it's a movie, and only about two hours, right? But won't it be funny if Jennifer Hudson steals the movie version? I can't be the only one laughing at the thought of that happening. Am I?

  • roc's blog
  • Login or register to post comments
  • Peachblossom720's picture

    My friends and I read this

    My friends and I read this news with both excitement and trepidation.  While I'm glad for Jennifer, I hope the role isn't the stereotypical sassy Black woman role, where no one in their right mind would hire her or want to be around her.  Just think of the majority of the roles for Black women on tv as an example of what we don't want to see.  That role has been beaten to death, and it is just so one dimensional.

    I enjoyed SATC, and it seems to me that if these writers can create four characters who are strong and very different from one another, they can create a three dimensional character who is a woman of color, and who has wants and ambitions of her own.

    roc's picture

    The ideal

    "seems to me that if these writers can create four characters who are strong and very different from one another, they can create a three dimensional character who is a woman of color, and who has wants and ambitions of her own."

    I certainly think it's possible. Especially given that the creative forces behind the TV series are still on board for the film. The writing for the show was clever and insightful and I expect the same for the movie. Plus, let us hope that Hudson wouldn't sign on if the role had a neon sign on it flashing "sassy black woman" or "sage black woman" stereotype:) In truth the movie will be about the original cast members and rightfully so. The four of them are the focus and learning what and where they have been for the last four years will be really fun for the faithful. On the other hand it is a movie. And movies entertain differently than TV and I am hoping that Hudson, even as a supporting actress will have more to do than being Carrie's side kick. Maybe she can be lousy at her job or have other priorities different than Carrie's and sort of be a nemesis in a way...I don't know, just something that doesn't suggest a "been there done that" relationship between the two characters. I'm on board and wishing for the best.

    SheHateMe's picture

    I already know that she is

    I already know that she is going to be another sister playing a sterotypical Mammy role. Its a shame that Black women are asked the play the same roles movie after movie. There was an article posted about this about a month ago. The saddest part about all this is the fact that although we recognize the trend there continues to be a perpetuation of the stereotype.





    " I will not have my life narrowed down. I will not bow down to somebody else's whim or to someone else's ignorance."
    - Bell Hooks
    tight's picture

    wait and see

    the AE blog article you mentioned is linked in this blog right in the beginning.

    the whole concept is frustrating but i'm taking a wait and see attitude. i loved satc so i'm happy a movie's coming out! cool! i've been psyched about this for awhile. i really don't want to think that the writers for this show would stoop to such a stereotype. i mean i bet the role was NOT written with hudson or anyone black in mind so maybe it was something small but then once negotiations for hudson's talents came into play it was expanded some. i know that has happened on other films. once the person is identified in the role more fleshing out can happen. so there's a chance it will go beyond mere driving miss daisy morgan freeman role. see to me that's the thing. i loved driving miss daisy. it was about old order and especially old southern order and it made sense to me given the historical context. but damn it's 2007 ya'll and there are a ton of black women and white women that really are true friends so why can't this real life balance pan out on screen? why does it have to be so lopsided and stupid? maybe it's because white guys are writing most of this sh*t? anyway, roc i'm with the idea that hopefully hudson didn't sign up to play a stereotype. hopefully she knows what the role is and that she signed up to really be a part of the mix and not a dang carrie side kick like you said. the truth will be revealed! lol

    pecola's picture

    Wait...

    ...there's black people in New York City?

    ::gasp::

    My biggest gripe about SATC has always been the lack of any people of color...in a show set in New York.

    roc's picture

    .....

    "...there's black people in New York City?"

    Actually, I don't think so. I asked the pals from Friends and they all said no:)

    shygurl99's picture

    Hmmm

    I love sex and the city but I admit, It did frustate me with the focus only being on women looking for a man for marriage and then the one not looking for marriage is basically have sex with anyone at anytime.I wonder how Jennifer will fit in the movie but it should be interesting.I admit...I'm still pissed about how the show ended even after all of these years

     

    "Life is either a daring adventure or nothing."-Helen Keller